Early access

Go or no-go: twelve questions to ask before you bid

A losing bid costs days of your best people's time. Twelve questions that separate the tenders worth bidding for from the ones to let go, and how to answer them in an hour.

It is easy to bid on too many public tenders. Each response takes days from the people who are also needed to deliver your current work, and a bid you were never going to win costs as much as one you were. The cure is a short, honest decision before the writing starts: go, or no-go.

These twelve questions fall into three groups: can we bid, can we win, and is it worth it. Most can be answered in an hour from the notice and the tender documents. If you are new to notices, start with how to read a TED notice in five minutes.

Can we bid?

These are pass or fail. One clear "no" ends the discussion, unless a partner can fill the gap.

1. Do we meet every selection criterion?

Minimum turnover, insurance cover, the number and size of comparable references, certifications, professional qualifications. Check each against what you can prove with documents, not what you believe to be true. If you fall short on one, ask whether a consortium partner or subcontractor could meet it, and whether the documents allow that.

2. Could any exclusion ground apply to us?

Under the EU directive, buyers must exclude companies for reasons such as unpaid taxes established by a court or authority, and may exclude them for others, such as insolvency or grave professional misconduct. Most companies are clear, but find out now, not on the day you sign the declaration.

3. Can we deliver everything that is mandatory?

Read the specification for the words "must" and "shall". A single mandatory requirement you cannot meet, such as a certified product, a local office or a response time, is a no-go, however good the rest of the fit.

4. Can we produce a good response in the time left?

Count working days, not calendar days, and subtract the time for internal reviews, signatures and uploading. Then ask who will write it, and what they will stop doing to make room.

Can we win?

These need judgement. Write down the answer and the reason, so the decision can be checked later.

5. How will the bids be scored, and where are we strong?

Find the award criteria and their weightings. If price carries most of the weight, ask whether you can be the cheapest credible bidder. If quality does, ask whether your method, team and evidence will score at the top of each criterion, not merely pass.

6. Do we understand what the buyer is trying to fix?

A specification lists requirements; it rarely explains why. A bidder who knows the problem behind the tender writes a sharper response. If you have never spoken to the buyer and the documents leave the purpose vague, your bid starts behind.

7. Is there an incumbent, and how is it doing?

A tender to replace an existing contract often has a supplier who knows the work, the people and the data. Past award notices show who won last time and for how much. An incumbent can be beaten, but you need a reason the buyer would want to change.

8. Who else will bid?

Estimate the field. A niche technical tender may draw three bids; a broad framework may draw dozens. The more bidders, the higher your score must be, and the lower your chance even with a good bid.

Is it worth it?

9. What is the work worth to us?

Not the headline value, but the margin you would make. A framework's value is a ceiling, not a promise: a place on a framework with many suppliers may bring little work. Estimate what you would realistically win over its life.

10. Can we accept the contract terms?

Liability caps, penalties, payment terms, intellectual property, insurance levels. Public contracts are often offered on fixed terms that you cannot negotiate after the award. Read them before you bid, and price the risk you take on.

11. Could we deliver it if we won?

Winning work you cannot staff hurts more than losing. Check that the people named in the bid would be free on the start date, and what else you would turn down.

12. Does it take us where we want to go?

A first contract with a new buyer, a new country or a new kind of work can be worth bidding for at a thinner margin. A contract that only keeps a team busy at low margin rarely is. Say which one this is.

Making the decision

  • Decide early. Make the call within a few days of the notice, before writing starts and the time already spent makes it harder to walk away.
  • Record it. Write down the answers, the decision, who made it, and the date. After the award, compare the reasons with the result. Over a year, the records show which kinds of tender you win.
  • Revisit it once. If the buyer's answers to questions change the picture, take the decision again, and be willing to stop.
  • Say no well. A no-go frees a team for a bid you can win. If the buyer matters to you, tell them why you are not bidding; it helps them write the next tender.

To find tenders worth asking these questions about, browse the open tender directory by sector and country.

Questions and answers

What is a go or no-go decision?

A short, honest decision, made before the writing starts, on whether a tender is worth bidding for. It rests on three questions: can we bid, can we win, and is it worth it.

When should you decide whether to bid?

Within a few days of the notice, before writing starts and the time already spent makes it harder to walk away. Take the decision again once if the buyer's answers to questions change the picture.

What makes a tender a clear no-go?

A selection criterion you cannot meet and no partner can fill, an exclusion ground that applies to you, or a single mandatory requirement you cannot deliver.

How long does a go or no-go review take?

Most of the twelve questions can be answered in an hour from the notice and the tender documents.

Is a framework's value what we would earn?

No. A framework's value is a ceiling, not a promise: a place on a framework with many suppliers may bring little work.

Sources
  1. Directive 2014/24/EU on public procurement: Article 57 (exclusion grounds), Article 63 (relying on other entities' capacity) and Article 67 (award criteria), checked 28 October 2026: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2014/24/oj

The Herald, free each working morning. One tender analysed in depth, then big tickets, quick wins, deadlines and awards. Engineering and Water first.

Get the Herald

Read next